Sometimes it works out, sometimes it doesn’t.

I read that Crowe took the role despite not liking the script. He was a fan of Robin Hood since he was a tyke.

http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/features/russell-crowe-angry-me-never-997593.html

I thought the 1938 film handled Robin’s “origin” well enough. (considering there are many different interpretations of the character). How was it lacking? You knew in the beginning through dialog he was a Lord, and retained that title until his confrontation with Guy of Gisbourne and Prince John in the banquet hall. After his daring escape John writes out a warrant and declares Robin’s land and title forfeit. Later on Marian asks Robin why he gave up his nobility and he gives a heartfelt answer. What else do you need?

it says in the post they’ve already started shooting.

So what was it, just a “we’re not so different you and I” in casting form? Well whatever the original idea was, I like this one! You could really do something with that.

maybe someone read that rumor on the web and decided, “THAT’S BRILLIANT!” i would love to see that!

That was NEVER part of the original draft. That was a misunderstanding and Scott’s quote being taken out of context.