(Sorry for no video version of this review, but I’m currently visiting out in LA) On this recent trip to LA, I was fortunate enough to have the studio invite me to a screening of Sweeney Todd with some of the cast and crew last week. It’s strange that I’ve been looking forward to this film so much, especially when you consider that I’m not a fan of Tim Burton’s at all (Although I’m one of the few people that thought he did a great job with Charlie and the Chocolate Factory).
For Sweeney Todd, Tim Burton once again brings Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter to his aid to tell the story of the demon barber of Fleet street. Just from the trailers you could tell that the visual style of the film would be fun to watch, but would the story be enough to carry it through… and would it work as a musical? These are the questions I had going in to Sweeney Todd.
THE GENERAL IDEA
Johnny Depp plays a young and talented barber in London. He has a wonderful life with a beautiful wife that he loves with his whole heart, and a baby daughter. Life is wonderful until one day the local corrupt Judge (Played by Alan Rickman) notices Depp’s wife and decides he wants her for his own. The Judge has Depp arrested on false charges and sent away to prison so he can move in and take his wife. 15 years have passed and Depp now returns to London a very different man. He changes his name to Sweeney Todd and all his hope, innocence and optimism are now replaced by anger, bitterness and thoughts of harsh revenge. To unleash his vengeance on the people of London, he takes up his old profession… but this time decides to give shaves a lot closer.
THE GOOD
As I suspected from the trailers, the visual style of Sweeney Todd is quite gorgeous. Burton captures the essence of the time period in London and does a slick job of taking you there to the dirty streets. Typical of Burton films, the screen is dark much of the time… only this time it was quite appropriate and used well. The set design and special visual effects were used together in such a way that environments were always great to look at… but never took away from what was happening on screen.
Johnny Depp. What can you really say about him? Even if you don’t like Depp (which I do) you’ve got to admit he can do the dark brooding thing really well. As a matter of fact, one of my favorite parts of the film was a semi-dream montage of supposedly HAPPY situations where everyone around is clearly joyful, but Sweeney consistently looks miserable… trust me it really worked. Depp was solid as expected and sets the tone for the whole film as a man robbed of his innocence, his wife, his child and clearly his sanity, fueled now by pure rage and anger. Very well done.
I’ve said it many times, but for films like this one, you have to have a solid villain figure for it to rise above mediocre… and who on earth will ever be as good at delivering that than Alan Rickman? As the corrupt Judge in London and the object of Sweeney Todd’s wrath, Rickman puts all of the evil and charm, sophistication and savagery. He is the worst and most dangerous kind of hypocrite…. the one that doesn’t even realize he is a hypocrite. You LOATHE Rickman for his villainy… but hate him even more when he’s eloquent . It was a huge challenge to have a character be the BAD GUY when Sweeney Todd is standing across from him and make Todd look more sympathetic… but Rickamn does it.
Two BRILLIANT small supporting roles in the film really stood out. Sacha Baron Cohen as a barbering competitor for Sweeney Todd was very funny, and you could literally feel the theater light up when he came on screen. BUT… even better was Timothy Spall who plays Rickman’s evil henchman. I swear Spall would have stolen the whole movie if he had much more screen time. Every moment he’s on there his presence captures you… so greasy, so foul and yet so funny. I loved him.
The story of the film was the strong point. A wronged man, returning to the city of his betrayal years later under a new identity seeking revenge on those who perpetrated the egregious offense on him. Watching his plan for revenge unfold and seeing those who get caught up in his destructive path all tied up with a satisfying ending.
THE BAD
Yes, I get it, I know Helena Bonham Carter looks goth, but so what? Some critic circles are giving carter mention for potential best supporting actress… but I simple didn’t see it. Don’t misunderstand me, I don’t thing Helena Bonham Carter was horrible in Sweeney Todd, but she was clearly a weak point who never would have been considered for this role had her husband not been the director (which is something mentioned a lot about her regarding more than half the movies she’s appeared in). Whenever she had dialog, or a song to sing, it felt like the movie just stopped. I don’t dislike Carter, but she wasn’t right for this part… but my opinion on this issue is in the minority.
The Music was bland, and for a musical that’s a big weakness. When we came out of Lion King, we were all humming hakuna matata or Circel of Life. When we came out of Moulin Rouge we were humming “This is your song” or “Come what may”… however the music in Sweeney Todd is utterly forgettable, and other than a few lines that are in the trailer, I’ve already forgotten all of it. Some may disagree, but this movie would have been 3x better had it not been a musical. Yes yes yes… I know the music is a part of it… but when adapting it to the screen I truly feel that Sweeny Todd would have been better off without being a musical. The story was strong, the performances were wonderful and honestly the musical numbers just got in the way… which wouldn’t have been the case if the music wasn’t so forgettable. To me, this was the one major flaw of Sweeney Todd.
OVERALL
Despite the fact that Sweeney Todd would have been better without being a musical, the story, performances, art… and yes I’ll say it… the DIRECTION (and I’m no Tim Burton Fan) were all strong enough to still make Sweeney Todd an enjoyably gruesome (it’s very gory) film with soul. I had a good time watching this film, and I think most of you will too. Not as good as I was hoping it would be, but certainly worth of your ticket money. Overall I give Sweeney Todd a 7.5 out of 10
